Failure to serve valid payment or pay less notices can create a substantial payment obligation before the underlying valuation dispute is resolved. This is commonly described as a “smash and grab” adjudication.
The financial consequences can extend beyond finding the money to pay. Establishing the true value of the works may involve further time and expense, while concerns about the recipient’s financial position may raise questions about whether any overpayment could ultimately be recovered.
Avanton Capital CC Ltd v LUC Construction Ltd [2026] EWHC 2630 (TCC), decided on 15 October 2026, illustrates those risks. Unusually, the employer was seeking payment from the contractor.
Competing adjudications over the final account
LUC was appointed by Avanton under a design and build contract to construct three industrial units. Following practical completion in April 2025, a dispute arose between the parties in relation to the final account.
LUC commenced seven adjudications in May 2026, all relating to valuation disputes. Avanton then brought its own adjudication, claiming that LUC had failed to serve valid payment notices against a notified sum of approximately £1.88 million.
Three decisions obtained by LUC reduced Avanton’s contra-charges by a combined £710,264. However, the adjudicator in the notified sum claim ordered LUC to pay the notified sum, together with interest and fees. The four remaining adjudicators subsequently resigned.
LUC argued that it would ultimately be entitled to recover money from Avanton and raised concerns about Avanton’s ability to repay any overpayment. LUC also maintained that immediate payment could force it to cease trading, preventing it from pursuing arbitration. On this basis, LUC sought a stay of enforcement.
When will the Court stay enforcement?
The courts generally enforce adjudicators’ decisions while the underlying dispute continues. A stay of execution may provide protection where the successful party would probably be unable to repay following a later determination. Showing that repayment is uncertain will generally not be sufficient.
The Court will also consider whether the financial risk is materially different from that accepted when the contract was made, and whether the successful party’s financial difficulties resulted from the other party withholding payment.
The paying party’s own financial position can exceptionally justify a stay where enforcement would cause manifest injustice. However, that requires evidence and where competing risks are finely balanced, the standard approach favours enforcement.
Why LUC’s evidence fell short
Avanton was a company established for the development, with little available cash, significant secured debt and negative net assets. Its reliance on discretionary group funding gave legitimate cause for concern.
Nevertheless, Avanton had previously received substantial financial support] from group companies, and there was evidence to suggest that, although not certain, this support would continue. LUC had not demonstrated that Avanton would probably lack the resources to repay after arbitration. The burden was to establish probable inability, rather than a possibility.
Although Avanton’s financial position had deteriorated, the Court was not persuaded that the risk of non-repayment had materially changed. Avanton was a special purpose company with limited assets, a position that LUC had been aware of when entering into the contract and which had not fundamentally changed.
LUC also failed to address what funding its shareholders or others could provide. Its evidence therefore did not establish that payment would prevent it pursuing arbitration. The Court refused a stay and entered judgment for approximately £1.6 million plus interest and fees.
The Court did not determine the disputed jurisdictional position or the wider effects of LUC’s separate valuation decisions.
The practical significance
The case emphasises the importance of payment and pay less notices to avoid these additional complications and risks from arising. Even if there are strong arguments on true value that may not remove an immediate payment obligation, and financial concerns do not automatically provide protection against enforcement.
If those concerns arise, early advice and properly supported financial evidence can help establish whether there is a realistic basis for seeking a stay or negotiating payment terms.
CCC assists with payment notices, payment disputes and adjudication. Contact us for a free initial one-hour consultation to discuss your contractual position and the practical options available.


